Of all the decisions made within companies, hiring is one of the most important. Unfortunately, too often, hiring decisions are made by people with little or no training in how to conduct the interview or assess a candidate. As a result, decisions are based on mostly irrelevant, basic questions such as ‘What are your strengths?’, ‘Why should we hire you?’. Or worse, they are based on intuition.

Companies do not need candidates that interview well. They require candidates that can do their job well. This means that the interviewer needs to know what they are doing and not base decisions on a gut feeling. Learning how to conduct the interview based on candidates’ skills and if they are fit for the company is an essential aspect of the hiring process.

How Can You Put Your Intuition in its Place in Hiring Decisions?

To put your intuition in its place in hiring decisions, you must manage subjectivity and rely on hard data, rather than gut feelings or instincts. Relying solely on intuition can lead to bad hires, poor job performance, and a less diverse workforce, as evidenced by research showing about one-third of new hires quit within the first six months due to attitude or poor performance. Just as other company sectors function with appropriate processes, hiring decisions require a structured approach to ensure candidates are assessed objectively.

Listening to your intuition can lead to bad hires, poor job performance, and a less diverse workforce. According to research done by BambooHR, about one-third of new hires quit within the first six months because of their attitude or poor performance. It’s not that intuition doesn’t have a place, but that you must know its place. To make the right hiring decision, you need to manage subjectivity and rely on hard data.

How Can You Park Your First Impressions During an Interview?

It is not possible to completely ignore intuition, and it’s also not advisable. However, you can acknowledge it and use a practice called ‘Parking your first impression’ to determine if your first impression is accurate. Before the interview starts, write down ‘Yes,’ ‘I don’t know,’ and ‘No.’ Once the interview begins, check one of the options indicating what your first impression is. Now, you can park it and not let it influence you. Otherwise, you will spend the entire interview trying to justify your first impression.

Leave a Reply

For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

Frequently Asked Questions

1 Why is trusting intuition in hiring decisions considered problematic?

Relying on intuition often leads to decisions based on first impressions or irrelevant factors rather than a candidate's actual skills and fit for the role. This approach can result in bad hires, poor job performance, and a less diverse workforce, as research indicates.

2 How can companies improve their hiring process to avoid relying on gut feelings?

Companies should provide interviewers with proper training on how to conduct effective interviews and assess candidates based on their skills and suitability for the company. This shifts the focus from subjective intuition to objective evaluation of a candidate's ability to perform the job well.

3 What are the potential negative outcomes of making hiring decisions based on intuition?

Making hiring decisions based on intuition can lead to significant negative consequences, including hiring individuals who are not a good fit for the role or company. This can result in poor job performance, increased employee turnover, and a less diverse workforce due to inherent biases.

4 What kind of training is essential for interviewers to make better hiring decisions?

Interviewers require training that teaches them how to conduct structured interviews and objectively assess candidates' skills and company fit. This training helps them move beyond basic, irrelevant questions and subjective gut feelings, ensuring decisions are based on a candidate's ability to do the job well.